What Screen Is The iPad – And Does It Matter?

Posted by Paul Colligan on Monday, February 22, 2010

There is a concept called the “fourth screen” (link goes to Wikipedia) that you need to be familiar with for this post to make sense. There’s actually a concept of the fifth screen (again, Wikipedia link) as well, but we need to chat about that later.

In short, the idea is that the “first” screen is the movie screen. The “second” is the television. The “third” is the computer. The “fourth” is any mobile screen (like a cell phone, iPod, or PDA).

I’ve been fascinated with the concept of the “fourth screen” because it is, in fact, the true power of what got me into Podcasting so quickly and so passionately. Being able to reach anyone at any place and at any time on that “fourth screen” has been such a pull for me.

The “fourth screen” concept gets a little murky with laptops and, now, the iPad. Are those “third” or “fourth” – or, something else?

This is an extremely important issue from a design an experience angle. I purposely try to make every piece of media I create effective for all the screens because I have an audience that spans them all (well, nobody watching Colligan.com at the movies yet). I recommend you take the same approach as it just makes sense. And it isn’t just me. If you don’t think Hollywood makes sure that the blockbuster Imax films will still work on my Mom’s SD television, you’re nuts.

Let’s admit it, there is only so much you can do with a few inches of phone space. “Fourth screen” marketing needs a gentle touch.

But with the iPad, I have to think a little bit outside of the box. If it’s just a “big iPhone” like some claim, then this will go away quickly.

But, if it is something very different, we need to ponder how we react with it.

Do we think in terms of a simple netbook - i.e., a “third screen” approach?

Do we think in terms of a bigger portable device – i.e., a “fourth screen” take on life?

Or, is this something very, to steal Apple’s term, “different?” If so, will we need to think of design, interaction, commerce, etc., in new terms to make way for what’s to come?

A “fifth screen” (not at all like the one described in Wikipedia above)?

One simple example. If you’ve heard my thoughts on mobile commerce, you know that I don’t think we’re going to see a ton of stuff purchased from a 9 digit phone on low battery. But an iPad on the bus, the classroom, at the airport, etc. We might be onto something very different here.

My gut tells me right now that this is, in fact, something very different. Maybe it’s the geek in me (or the Apple Fan Boy) – or something else. So, … here’s what I’m going to do about it.

The details will be tracked at PaulsiPad.com, but in short, I’m going to buy an iPad the day it comes out and run my business on nothing but the iPad for 30 days. Should be fascinating to say the very least.

So, I end with a few questions that I hope you’ll take a minute or two to answer:

What screen number is the iPad?

Does it matter?

Am I nuts – or on to something?

I look forward to your response ….

Update: I’ve launched A YouTube Channel for Paul’s iPad to keep up to date with great iPad videos (and some stuff I’ll make myself).


 
Tagged as: ,
  • http://scottmaiorca.wordpress.com/ Scott Maiorca

    In the way I think McLuhan used the term yes. It’s more than a big iphone, b/c you can actually read and interact with. It’s created a possibly better delivery method for content. I assume the apps market will shift that way, taking advantage of the new ideas used for the iphone/touch. I also assume it’s a lot easier on the eyes for reading than the touch or the Iphone. If this is the case then people will deliver content to take advantage of it’s strengths and then it’ll be a new medium.

  • http://scottmaiorca.wordpress.com/ Scott Maiorca

    I think you're on to something. Sort dancing around the ideas expressed by Marshall Mcluhan. The media or medium inherently influences the message. Good job!

  • paulcolligan

    Is the iPad a new medium?

  • http://www.douglassandquist.com Doug S

    I think you are on to something here… I'm thinking about course work delivered via podcast…. listen with headphone and work on worksheets as you listen… I'm thinking it will become a great platform for consuming content delivered via Premiumcast…. Pdfs with embedded links to media files, listen to this file as you work through this worksheet… im guessing we'll have to see a version that multi tasks before much of this is realized… but I guess the courses could be delivered via App…

  • http://scottmaiorca.wordpress.com/ Scott Maiorca

    In the way I think McLuhan used the term yes. It's more than a big iphone, b/c you can actually read and interact with. It's created a possibly better delivery method for content. I assume the apps market will shift that way, taking advantage of the new ideas used for the iphone/touch. I also assume it's a lot easier on the eyes for reading than the touch or the Iphone. If this is the case then people will deliver content to take advantage of it's strengths and then it'll be a new medium.

  • paulcolligan

    Doug,

    Honestly, never thought about that process – but I love it. It's on the white board right now. Thanks for bringing it up.

  • paulcolligan

    Well the chat on this post has been less than usual – but the quality has been amazingly high. Yeah, I think this will become something very different. And, in the end, I don't think Apple will be the only game in town – they're just the ones who introduced us to it all.

  • http://scottmaiorca.wordpress.com/ Scott Maiorca

    It's the process that Doug mentions that makes it a new medium.I can't wait till the online schools I teach for start using the pad, or its competitor for my students rather than the computers we currently use. I think the integrated applications will enhance student learning by hitting multiple learning styles at once.

  • http://emotrance.eu/ Detlev Tesch

    My guess is that the iPad – and the derivatives and me-toos that will inevitably follow – will change the way many, many people deal with computers coz there will be a new type of computer or forth/fifth screen. ((I don't care too much about that arbitrary classification – even though it makes some sense it is murky, indeed.))

    Take my mom. She's 71 and uses a laptop running Vista for email, a little bit of surfing, playing a few games, typing recipes and the like.

    She doesn't WANT to deal with a “computer” much less an operating system. She recently managed somehow to lose most her files because the machine sometimes tells her “cryptic” stuff and she does not really know what to do – it is not logical *to her*. So someone had to come and fix things for her for a fee (she lives far away so neither my brother nor I can help).

    The iPad would be just about perfect for her if it could print and scan. And possibly she might put up with out printing and scanning for the ease of use. More so if the thing didn't need a computer at all – or does it?

    With the iPad and iPad-like devices we will do more in what used to be “dead time” like Lynn Terry said in IMTW recently, and I totally agree. And it will be more fun than it used to be, less hassle, quick and easy.

    And I agree with Doug here re the “great platform for consuming content”. In-app purchases of digital products (like via PremiumCast) will not be limited to ebooks like on the Kindle (and, again in IMTW, you told us how you bought Kindle books on the fly during calls). This is so fantastic. This will open a market big time, even more than the iPhone did.

    A lot of what I do on my iMac wouldn't require a fully fledged computer! An iPad might just do. Especially since they have Pages and Keynote apps. So I am very much looking forward to your 30 days on only iPad project and your findings.

    I expect the iPad as we know it to be somewhat of an entry level product with more high end devices following in the near future. This is the model of interacting with computers for the majority.

    Look at how may cell phones are out there now that mimik the iPhone, how many touchscreens with similar icons etc. I say it is going to happen again with the iPad.

    And I like that.

  • paulcolligan

    I”m enjoying this conversation tremendously. Thanks for thinking this stuff through.

  • http://www.david-miles.com/ipad/your-business-on-an-ipad David Miles

    Well you know my thoughts on the matter of you running your business for 30 days on the iPad alone : ) I personally think if you can pull this off you're really onto something… (I'm confident you're going to pull it off for 30 days but this is not going to replace your computer anytime soon)

    With regarding to the screen number of the iPad, while its mobile but I wouldn't consider it an iPhone or an iPod touch but more in the category of the smaller net book (for a lack of better words) so as of right now give it a 3.5 lol

    The concept of the iPad is going to change the third and fourth screen and I personally believe that when this catches on big time (not just the early adapters like you) we will be seeing a lot more things just like the iPad hit the market. Like tablets that run Windows and much more… (I know that these things already exist and have seen a few of them but they haven't really made it big yet) .Currently based on the information that I have about the iPad and after reading numerous reviews and talking to people in the market I still think it's a relatively overgrown iPhone 3G… which don't get me wrong you can do a lot with it and since it's got a bigger screen it's all a lot more user-friendly, and I don't know of anyone trying to run their business for more than a day off their iPhone 3G … (I know I've tried it while traveling and it's really no fun)

    With regarding to your question about “are you nuts” NO you're far from nuts I think you're going to have a lot of fun and learn a lot about the iPad and become an instant expert … what one level higher than an expert let's call it the iPad Guru, all within 30 days… and as you said in your post you're an Apple Fan Boy so I'm betting in your day-to-day you mostly use Apple computers so syncing up your iPad is not really to be such a big issue compared to the PC guys (like me).

    One last note:
    Now that I think about it since to my understanding the iPad does not will allow multitasking meaning running more than one program at a time or if it does allow it it's not so convenient, I think that you might become a little more productive meaning only working on one task at a time and being forced to work on that task without any distractions with other programs running in the background and so on…

  • paulcolligan

    Yes, the monotasking “feature” of the iPad I think will let me get a LOT more work done.

  • paulcolligan

    Yes, the monotasking “feature” of the iPad I think will let me get a LOT more work done.

  • http://www.facebook.com/standubin Stan Dubin

    The iPad screen number is 3.5.

    It does matter.

    You are not nuts.

  • georgekedourie

    Gonna be interesting. I will look forward to how you 'get' the ipad.
    I know that I love having the iphone for all my communication stuff. Much prefer not using computer time for reading my mails and Facebook. I think for apps and the one we are doing it will be great.
    I was hoping for multitasking so if you find that you can leave a program and get back to where you were…OK. However if every time you leave a program and go back you have to return to the beginning of that program it won't be so easy to work for thirty days…I think.
    What about making videos.Will it have iMovie or similar?
    Best,
    George

  • paulcolligan

    It matters a lot.

  • paulcolligan

    It won't have iMovie – but there are some 3rd party apps for editing.

    However, that's not what these things are for. This is an issue of computing when you don't need a lot of power.

    My favorite video editor is a guy named Mark – I can easily forward him directions on my iPad. When I need to do some editing myself (and everytime I do it myself, I lose money), I'll do on my big machine at home.

    Obviously during those 30 days …